Bhekisiswa ontanga ukulinganisa umsebenzi okwenziwa ngumuntu oyedwa noma abaningi abanamakhono afanayo njengabakhiqizi bomsebenzi (ontanga). Isebenza njengendlela yokuzibamba ngamalungu afanelekile wezobuchwepheshe ngaphakathi kwalokhu ofanele field. Izindlela zokubuyekezwa kontanga zisetshenziselwa ukugcina izindinganiso zekhwalithi, ukuthuthukisa ukusebenza, nokunikeza ukuthembeka. In Academia, ukubuyekezwa kontanga kwezazi isetshenziswa kaningi ukuthola i iphepha lokufundaUkufaneleka kokushicilelwa.

Kusuka ku-Wikipedia, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peer_review

Izimpendulo kanye nokubuyekezwa kontanga

Umbhalo wesandla wokuqala unguqulo yombhali ye-athikili futhi imvamisa ihanjiswa kujenali ukuze ibuyekezwe ontanga. Ngokwesiko, ibhodi yokuhlela yejenali libhekele ukuhlanganiswa kwenqubo yokubuyekezwa.

Izinhlelo zokubuyekezwa kontanga zihluka phakathi kokungaziwa noma 'okungaboni', ukungaboni okubili nokungavuleki kontanga futhi kuncike ekutheni umbhali kanye nombuyekezi bayazi ngobunikazi bomunye nomunye noma cha futhi uma umbiko wokubuyekezwa utholakala esidlangalaleni noma kuphela ebhodini lokuhlela le iphephabhuku nombhali.

Namuhla, izindlela ezahlukahlukene zokubuyekezwa kontanga zikhona ezinye esizethula lapha. Abanye abalingani bethu ahlinzeke ngezinsizakalo ezifaka noma ezinikezela ngengqalasizinda yedijithali yokuchazwa kombhalo kanye nokubuyekezwa kontanga kombhalo wakho wesandla.

Ukwamukela noma ukunikeza impendulo kulungiselelwa okubanjelwe epulatifomu ye-KiaArXiv siphakamisa izinketho ezilandelayo:

Imibhalo yokubuyekezwa komphakathi ivuliwe Ukubuka kabusha

Umsebenzi wePrereview ukuletha ukwehluka okuningana ekubuyekezweni kontanga ngokwezifundo ngokusekela kanye nokunika amandla umphakathi wabaphenyi, ikakhulukazi labo abasezigabeni zokuqala zomsebenzi wabo (ama-ECR) ukubukeza okwandulelayo.

Ku-PREreview sikholelwa ukuthi bonke abacwaningi kufanele bavunyelwe ukusiza abanye ngokubukeza umsebenzi wontanga babo, inqobo nje uma kwenziwa ngokwakha.

Ukuqeqesha abacwaningi ukuthi banikeze impendulo eyakhayo
Ngokuyindida, ngenkathi ukubukeza kontanga kuyingxenye esemqoka yokusakazwa kwesayensi, bambalwa kakhulu ososayensi abathola noma yikuphi ukuqeqeshwa okusemthethweni kukho.

Funda kabanzi ku- okuqukethwe.prereview.org/about/

Thumela umbhalo wakho wesandla I-PeerCommunityIn

I-Peer Community ku… (PCI) yinhlangano yesayensi engenzi inzuzo esekelwe eFrance ehlose ukudala imiphakathi ethile yabaphenyi abukethayo futhi bayancomela, mahhala, ukubhala okungashicilelwe emkhakheni wabo.
I-PCI inikezela ngenqubo yokuncoma yamahhala yamalungiselelo wesayensi (kanye nemibhalo eshicilelwe) ngokususelwa ekubuyekezweni kontanga.

  • Hambisa ilungelo le-PCI lokuyobuyekezwa (Kanjani).
  • Abacebisi be-PCI banayo Izinsuku ezingama-20 zokuthatha isinqumo kulwandiso lwakho.
  • Uma sekubanjwe umphathi, umnikazi wakho uzobuye abukezwe yontanga okungenani ababuyekezi ababili.
  • Uyamukela obukezayo namazwana wokuphawula ukuze ulungiselele Isibuyekezo esibukeziwe se-Prerint yakho.
  • I-PCI inikeza isifanekiso kumbhali ukulungiselela inguqulo yokugcina yombhalo ngama-logo we-PCI kanye nesethenjwa sesincomo.
  • Ukuncoma nemibiko yokubuyekezwa kushicilelwe kuwebhusayithi yePCI. Uhlobo lwe-pdf lokunconywa kwe-PCI nemibiko yokubuyekezwa ingafakwa kungomlando womlobi njengoba izinto zokwengeza.
  • Izincomo ze-PCI zommeli wokuqala zithola a I-Crossref DOI elixhumeke kwirekhodi lasekuqaleni le-inthanethi.
  • Vuselela irekhodi lakho langaphambi kwepulatifomu ye-KiaArXiv kufaka phakathi isincomo se-PCI.
  • Umbambiso onconyiwe usengathunyelwa kujenali. Funda kabanzi ku- peercommunityin.org/pci-friendly-journals.

Mbhalo wesandla ongaziwa Hypothes.is

Uhlelo lokusebenza le-browser kanye ne-bookmarklet Hypothes.is inika amandla ukuthatha-inothi kwamazinga noma imisho ngaphezulu kwezindaba, ama-blogi, izihloko zesayensi, izincwadi, imigomo yokusebenza, imizamo yokuvota, umthetho nokuningi.
Kwesinye isikhathi okubizwa ngokuthi 'ukubuyekezwa kontanga yomphakathi' ungafunda futhi ukhiphe imibhalo yesandla eyamukelwe kunoma yiliphi ipulatifomu lomlingani wethu osebenzisa iHypothes.is - uzenzele noma wenze izichasiselo zakho zibe sesidlangalaleni kwabanye abasebenzisi beHypothes.is.
Amaphrinta we-OSF okubala AfricArXiv / OSF nezinye izinsiza zokuphrinta komphakathi zihlangana nazo Hypothes.is ukwenza okuvelele komphakathi nezichasiselo kufundwe kunoma ngubani.

Funda kabanzi ku- usizo.osf.io/…Annotate-a-Preprint futhi web.hypothes.is/research/.

Bukeza esidlangalaleni noma iyiphi i-athikili IsayensiOpen

IsayensiOpen kuyipulatifomu etholakalayo enezici ezisebenzayo zezazi zokuthuthukisa ucwaningo lwazo obala, zinomthelela, futhi zithole udumo ngalo.

Nikeza noma uthole ukubuyekezwa kontanga okuhlelekile kunoma yiziphi izindatshana zocwaningo ezingaphezu kwezigidi ezingama-60 namarekhodi akwi-inthanethi endaweni yesikhulumi seScienceOpen. Funda kabanzi ku- mayelana.scienceopen.com/peer-review-guidlines/.

Ngayo I-AfricaArXiv Preprints ukuqoqwa ku IsayensiOpen kungenzeka ukuthi ababhali bacele abanye abacwaningi ukuthi banikeze isibuyekezo sontanga esimisiwe ekhasini lokuqala lemibhalo ngqo epulatifomu leSayensiOpen. Funda kabanzi ku- scienceopen.com/collection/SOPreprints

Izinkombandlela Zokuziphatha Zokubuyekezwa Kontanga

Ukuqinisekisa ukuthembeka kwamarekhodi ezifundo kanye nokwenza lula ukubuyekezwa okungaguquki, okulungile futhi okufika ngesikhathi, sincoma ukulandela imihlahlandlela yoMkhandlu we-COPE yabahlaziyi bontanga, engatholwa ku editionethics.org/files/Ethical_Guidlines_For_Peer_Reviewers.pdf

Ukwamukela ukuvuma komphakathi izabelo zakho zokuhlola ungakusebenzisa

  1. layisha umbiko wokubuyekezwa ku-KiaArXiv ngemuva kokushicilelwa komsebenzi obukeziwe ngababhali.
    • engeza i-DOI yendatshana ekhishwe njengereferensi
    • qiniseka ukuthi abahleli bamaphephabhuku nababhali bayavuma
  2. bhalisa isibuyekezo ku- publons.com.

Uma kwenzeka unemibuzo ekuhlolweni kokubuyekezwa kontanga okuqhutshwa ngumphakathi kwemibhalo yesandla eyakhiwe kuqala ungaxhumana nathi lapho info@africarxiv.org.

Okubhekwayo

UMkhandlu we-COPE. Imihlahlandlela yokuziphatha yalabo ababuyekeza ontanga. Septhemba 2017. | e-bookethics.org

UTennant, JP, Ross-Hellauer, T. Ukulinganiselwa kokuqonda kwethu ukubuyekeza kontanga. I-Res integrated Peer Rev5, 6 (2020). doi.org/10.1186/s41073-020-00092

accumsan ut ante. ipsum amet, IP idesent